Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
Nonsensical Ship by KrissyBKillin Nonsensical Ship by KrissyBKillin
Fueled by talking on SEGA forums.
And that I don't like my previous stamps :|
They all FUGLYYY.

Anyway: template by `DoItForTheLulz

Sally sprite by ~E-122-Psi
Sonic sprite from [link]


Anyway: My reasoning:
I am a fan who hates the idea of Sonic really having a steady relationship. I really am. Although I feel that if he DID have one, Amy would be his best choice, I think he shouldn't unless it's needed.
And do you guys know why this is so? It is very simple.
His character.

Sonic is a character that is BASED ON FREEDOM. That is all that Sonic is based on. Freedom is his life, and his motive. And it takes the form in his being not only a hero, but simply the "world's fastest hedgehog".
The reason that he loves running is the feeling of freedom that goes with it.
In truth, freedom is sorta what makes Sonic, Sonic.

So please, can somebody tell me why it is that this character who IS based on freedom would even want to be tied down?
NOT having the blessing of somebody who is willing to keep up with HIM; but being tied down.

Because that is all that is going to happen with a certain Chipmunk character we all know I hate.
Sally Acorn is a character based on control. Have you guys noticed this? Sally is a person who grew up as a princess:
she was taught from a young age that she needs to be responsible, and she needs to be a leader. And she was also taught that in order for this to happen she needs to be in control of the situation. [I get this from who her father is: the guy who is continuously fighting to keep control on his former kingdom even now]
Sally is always proclaimed as the strategist; this would have ALSO contributed to her need to be controlling of the situation.

But that is not all. Recently Sally's development has shown that Sally is the type of person who needs people to be there for her. She depends upon people and she is insecure about loosing people she cares about.

Those two traits: Controlling and Possessive/Dependent are what makes up her character.
And so that leads us back to my question:

If this chick IS a controlling and possessive person, then why the heck would a guy who is all about FREEDOM and INDEPENDENCE want to be in a relationship with her?

It does not make sense.
It will never make sense.
People will try to argue that they are supposed to be able to "compromise". Yeah: No. Sit Down.

Sonic is many things, but he is never a compromiser. He doesn't WORK like "Okay, I see both sides now I'll find an answer".
He is the person who will run into trouble without knowing or caring about what side you are on as long as he is doing what is right.
He will not change for another person.
It's not going to happen.

But it is also not likely to happen with Sally either.
Although Sally is supposed to be able to be level headed and compromising, she has shown that there is a limit for her.
Take the slapping scene where she calls Sonic selfish for his choosing his lifestyle over her.
She can compromise when it comes to policy or government, but emotionally she isn't quite that capable.

Add a Comment:
Red-The-Mink Featured By Owner Jun 13, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
She FORCED Sonic to retire, as well as the other Freedom Fighters.
IvoryAlmonds Featured By Owner Edited Mar 7, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Let's not forget that usually, in order for the shipping to work, it either was at the costed both Sonic and Sally's character, friendships, or even others around them. I noticed that it wasn't just Sonic being massively screwed over, but actually Sally too. There was a lot of lacking consistency in her writing, especially when to solely fit the aspect of being Sonic's foiler/tool. There were also times where her writing and actual character growth was contradicted and brushed aside for it as well.

The same can be DEFINITELY said for Sonic. Especially when Sonic actually admitted that he wouldn't want a relationship because he wouldn't have time for his friends.  (That's basically what happened. Probably even more so. Some characters were distanced away, pushed aside or to each other, turned out of character, and even deprived from their roles for romance to occur.) He pointed precisely to SALLY and MINA, which is ironic, because those are the ones he had affairs and romantic relations with later on.

What made him change his mind so vastly?

Sally and Sonic were always thrown back into the same space and stage in order to keep up with the shipping. They faced the same challenges and gained nothing from it but climatic events that can be predictable. When they could have potentially gained something from it to balance their character/dynamic, it was either brushed off, ignored in sake of risking SonAlly's end, or given a half arsed/strawmanned reasons for it NOT to take place. Another thing I'd love to add. All of the characters who had at least a bit of chemistry with Sally and Sonic that posed a threat, were basically shot down/distanced/ and the writers hid behind, as I will say again and have been saying, strawmanned reasonings.  (I am looking at Fiona the Fox. She was glaringly OoC for SonSal to take place. Going for Scourge after bluntly expressing her distaste for and with his treatment? Scourge accept her or fall for her after showing that he overall preferred Rouge? Making Fiona the 'bad girl' for nitpicks that already were basically redundant and already resolved? Really? I can literally rant onward about her ill/lazy treatment.)

The only reason why Amy wasn't wreaked was simply because the writers avoided using her because the 'mandates said no'. I'd really respect that reasoning, but the writers, I mean Ian, had danced around mandates quite a few times. To be honest, I think that's the only string that was saving him. I hope he does know that, yes, Sonic and Amy's relations CAN'T be defined romantically nor actually confirmed. Yet, nor given a yes OR A NO. It's simply supposed to be a gag, or nobody knows where the feelings resides on Sonic's side. Not simply 'Just no. It sucks. Sonic likes other girls >:U (MOSTLY SALLY!!!1!)'.

 Even if Amy wasn't 'wreaked' as a character, she wasn't as nearly established, and her relation/some appearances were basically an 'F YOU!' to the fans of SonAmy and Amy. I'm talking SPECIFICALLY about those issue covers too. Having Amy angst-y/whinny in the back, while Sonic and Sally obviously flirt or have attraction between the two, isn't the way to go. Nor showing professions. Just their fanboyism/bias for SonAlly and obvious denounces of other ships. At the very least they could have remained neutral and open to interpretations for the fans. Ah but no, it is too much of a threat for the precious pairing made up above.

What was worse is when Ian attempted to give reversed flaws, making Sally the fast and arrogant one and Sonic the control freak when cracked underneath pressure to make them appear more 'compatible' or 'alike'. Now it may seem like a good factor (That I strongly admit wouldn't mind seeing fold out.), but how he was molding it, it seemed as if he would make them basically hypocrites. What could have been, wasn't REALLY solved. 

*rubs head *

Oh all the positive writings/growth that could have happened for you, but didn't because of 'x'. If it did, then it was probably overshadowed. This led me to conclude that this is too a nonsensical AND BADLY written ship in the archie universe. Cry run Not that the character/personality aspect of the pairing even made sense to begin with. :/

Thank you, reboot. One cannot express how many words I have for you.
ArmorofHappiness Featured By Owner Mar 1, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yeah....I don't know if I can really see Sonic and Sally as a friends? Perfect! Meow :3 Meow :3 
IvoryAlmonds Featured By Owner May 12, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
ArmorofHappiness Featured By Owner May 18, 2017  Hobbyist Digital Artist
TheRedThunderX Featured By Owner Jan 20, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
As much as like Sally as a character I just don't see Sonally together so I agree on here.
KyraTheWolf0001 Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Yes thats so true
AlphaLordCalypso Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Exactly!! See, this is why I ship sondash (in an au mlp where she's in the sonic world) they both love freedom. Neither would have to feel tied down by the other, because they're both fast paced, and they both love freedom. 
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jul 17, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
However, they could crash of the ego boosts. I simply like SonDash as friends. Because similarities, doesn't equal love and happiness.
AlphaLordCalypso Featured By Owner Jul 18, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yeah, egos might be a problem. This is true, but honestly similarities makes more sense to me that opposite attract.
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jul 19, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
Thats why I like SonAmy.

- Both are free spirits.

- Both crave the life of freedom.

- get bored easily.

- both heroines.

- Both love to run.

- Both get obnoxious.

- Both do tend to have the same actions while apart.

However, Amy had differences that could assist him, vice versa.

- She exceeds in chores and basic necessities, which Sonic needs to take care of,

- He is more independent and calm
AlphaLordCalypso Featured By Owner Jul 19, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yeah, I like somamy too, especially in the sonic boom show. I don't really see him having any interest in her in any other media, but it seems more believable in this world.
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jul 19, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
Yep. I do see their moments, though. I can tell when he secretly admires her, or is annoyed. xD
AlphaLordCalypso Featured By Owner Jul 19, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yeah, those moments are both hilarious and sweet! :) 
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jul 19, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
Mushroom-Boy Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016
Sally is such a bitch to be honest, the writers of the Archie comics have to put her everywhere. She's pretty much like Princess Peach for me; she steals others' spotlights, she was simply made as someone for Sonic to love, and she's really annoying.
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jun 27, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
I love this stamp. Is that bad c:
CheetaHamSloth Featured By Owner Jun 17, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
If we talk seriously about it I'm totally agree. Sonic is a free soul. I can see him flirting with girls, but not serious compromise.
Allstaraleena Featured By Owner May 17, 2016
Wait, i though Queen Aleena was Sonic's mother? How is Sally the princess? She's not Queen Aleena daughter. Wait, i though Aleena was Sonic mother not... never mind. But, Sonic's the prince of Mobuis not Sally or Elias. Wait, how did Queen Alicia become Queen if Queen Aleena is the ruler? I am so confused right now?
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jun 27, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
1: Queen Aleena being his mother, and Sonia and Manic being his siblings is cannon in its own world, Sonic Underground. It isn't the main cannon. The game (true Sonic and mainstream Sonic), doesn't know

- Sally, who is cannon in Archie, SATAM, and DiC America.

- Elise was erased from the timeline along with 'Sonic '06'.

- Aleena, who isn't his mom in the true cannon.

2: Sonic isn't royalty in the real cannon.

3: Queen Alica was the ruler of kingdom ACORN, I don't think mobius.
Girl-Time-2015 Featured By Owner Apr 3, 2016
I like Sonic without a girlfriend, that is what makes him appealing to me. People never complained about Sherlock Holmes or TinTin or Merida not having a love interest. That what makes them good characters:they can do things without being tied down to someone. And if they were to have a romance, that romance should not be able to fully define them as people nor overshadow the entire story (aka Romantic Plot Tumor). Their love interests should also be interesting as characters too and not be fully defined as x's girlfriend/boyfriend.
However if Sonic were to be with someone, it would be Blaze or Amy.
ILoveFanficCritic2 Featured By Owner Jan 20, 2016  Hobbyist
But Sally DID change for the better. Archie rebooted their comics and Sally is no longer obsessed with Sonic, in fact, they're just friends.
qwilburn100 Featured By Owner Nov 27, 2015
I don't like SonAlly.
SparklyStarLights Featured By Owner Nov 14, 2015  Student Digital Artist
No Sonic couple makes sense, because Sonic is a free spirit, Yuji Naka said he was never going to get a lady in the games. (IN THE GAMES, in the another universes he can do it)

The good thing about the Sonic franchise is that people can ship whatever they want, because there's no canon couple! But the only problem is the fandom, I hate it when they bitch about different opinions, I ship Sonaze but I won't bitch at the Sonamy\Sonally fans.
IvoryAlmonds Featured By Owner Dec 1, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
* Claps loudly *

I agree fully, but in vice versa, I am a sonamy fan that will not scream at SonAze and SonAlly fans. 
SparklyStarLights Featured By Owner Dec 5, 2016  Student Digital Artist
Good to see that there are sonamy fans who dont bitch at sonally/sonaze fans :3
IvoryAlmonds Featured By Owner Dec 5, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Yep. Its a refreshing sight. *whispers* I have friends who love SONALLY and SONAZE.
SparklyStarLights Featured By Owner Dec 15, 2016  Student Digital Artist
I have friends who love sonamy and sonally as well xD
IvoryAlmonds Featured By Owner Dec 26, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Tails-and-Silver-Fan Featured By Owner Jan 26, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Pelo o que eu sei, Yuji Naka disse que Sonic nunca vai se casar com a Amy. E, por causa daquelas ordens da SEGA of Americau acho que os couples nunca vão se tornar canon nem mesmo nos spin-offs como a archie, sonic boom ou sonic x por causa daquelas ordens da SEGA of America. Eles disseram que Amy não pode se interessar em outro que não seja Sonic e além disso disseram que nenhum personagem pode ter relações sérias e também disseram: Sonic is single. Ou seja nenhum couple é canon.

Concordo. Qualquer um pode shipar o que quiser, mas os fãs abusam demais. É por isso que eu detesto a fandom do Sonic. Ninguém tem respeito. Sério e muita criançisse.
SparklyStarLights Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2016  Student Digital Artist
Concordo, os couples foram uma das razões que eu sai do fandom do Sonic, no meu fandom atual tem esse tipo de coisa também, mas não tanto que nem no fandom do Sonic
Tails-and-Silver-Fan Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Sim é verdade. Veja só o que um fanbrat fez. Só porque não gosta do grupo (imagino que é por causa do grupo ser popular) ele criou um anti-grupo para esse grupo. Ridículo mesmo -> antishadowxamylove.deviantart.…
Um monte de gente diz que a fandom do Sonic é a pior, até esse site diz isso ->…
Mas eu acredito que a fandom de Justin Bieber e a de times de futebol do Brasil é pior do que a do Sonic.
SparklyStarLights Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2016  Student Digital Artist
Nossa, ouvi falar que o fandom do Steven Universo é o pior, li por aí que aquele fandom tem vários SJWs(coloca no google, eu não sei explicar direto o que que é), e eles fizeram coisas horriveis, e o fandom do FNAF era considerado o pior fandom de 2014, mas agora eles não tão mais
Tails-and-Silver-Fan Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Eu olhei agora pouco. Gente insultou a usuária Zamii porque não desenhou os personagens do jeito que deveria ser. Mas por causa disso eles tem que ficar fazendo comentários de matá-la? E ela quase se suicidou. Que coisa horrível. Sobre esses SJWs pelo que eu entendi são pessoas que insultam outros por acharem que estão sendo preconceituosos de acordo com a raça ou gênero. Praticamente querem fazer justiça com as próprias mãos. A five night at freedy é aquela fandom que tem um urso esquisito e um monte de personagem que parece de halloween. O site top teen considera o fnaf uma das piores. Agora é só o que falta o undertale ficar assim também. Eu estava olhando essa fandom, já começaram a fazer couples, só para começar a brigarem.
SparklyStarLights Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2016  Student Digital Artist
Sim, é exatamente assim o fandom do Steven Universo

Sim, fnaf é isso mesmo, eu estou querendo entrar no fandom do Undertale, mas eu estou vendo que não vai dar... vai ser o novo fnaf de 2016
Tails-and-Silver-Fan Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Deve dar nisso mesmo. Esse undertale está crescendo demais. Voce viu aquela animação do Undertale que aparece como resultado quando a gente envia uma imagem na categoria games? Ridículo conseguiu um monte de views. Não sei como.
(1 Reply)
SepperAlways7 Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Okay, Sally had a reason to slap Sonic.
It's not that she's controlling. Yes, she grew up as a princess, but it doesn't fully make her possessive.
The only reason why she slapped was because she was so worried that he's going to get himself killed like he usually does.
Knowing Sonic, when he has freedom, he looks for trouble which is why Sally worries so much.
That's why he wanted her to stay. I mean, do you really think a SINGLE princess can handle an entire land alone.
She's still learning.
Plus, Sonally is the most fitting ship I know, unlike Sonamy. It looked nice because of fanart, but really, Amy is just plain irritating.
She's just that one stalker fangirl that has a crush on Sonic. Have you noticed that Sonic will ONLY see her as a friend? That's the way
it will always be. Don't even bother saying it makes sense because they're both hedgehogs. That's the cheapest excuse every Sonamy
fan has ever used, so don't even try. Plus, she. Would. Not. Sacrifice. Herself. To. Get. Roboticized. Like. Sally. Did.
That was a really big sacrifice Sally made, and most Sonamy fans are happy about that which makes me sick.
Even Amy cares about Sally. They are friends. Enough said.
Feel free to rant on me
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jun 27, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter

1: The only reason why she slapped was because she was so worried that he's going to get himself killed like he usually does.

Correction. She slapped him because she believed that he'd be 'safer' ruling with her rather than saving innocent lives.

Amy done this too. BUT DIDN'T SLAP HIM.

Issue 231, when Sally is Mecha Sally...

Sonic was hurt. BADLY. But he still wanted to battle.

Unlike Sally, who flared off at his strong willed demeanor, (Not saying AMY is better then her.) She clasped her hands over his and tried gently to hold him back.

"Sonic! Look, you can barely stand!" AND "Sonic---NO! You are in no condition to fight."

She shown genuine concern whilst everyone was debating with Sonic to stay. She was hugging him and crying. When she found out that he was too persistent, did she slap him and say he was selfish and get mad that he didn't listen? No. She actually was one of the few that came with him. Along with tails. Her fear over him getting hurt over shadowed her dreams with being with him.

2: She isn't GRASPING that SONIC is a FREE SPIRIT. HE ISN'T HER PET TO CONTAIN. Can't you just get someone else to rule with? He isn't royalty, and he doesn't have TRAINING EITHER.

3: Plus, Sonally is the most fitting ship I know,

No. It isn't. In fact, it is quite unhealthy.

They break up because a simple disagreement?

Then come back together because they can't stand the fact that they can't be without each other and see each other with another person?

No. Its both OoC, and not Sonic's style.

Sally can be wreak less as much Sonic is. And they disguise it with the 'opposite attracts' physiology.

4: Amy is just plain irritating.
She's just that one stalker fangirl that has a crush on Sonic. Have you noticed that Sonic will ONLY see her as a friend?

Amy is a sweet, girl, who is passionate about the things she cares about.

She isn't a 'stalker', she just chases her dreams. She isn't JUST a fangirl. She has uprooted herself and stood solid against that debate. Amy has also proven herself to his aid, and not all self centered around him.

Helping Shadow?

Saving Omega?

Saving a bird and helping it find its family?

Who are you to say 'he views her as a friend'. I disagree with that, hence the fact that Sonic isn't the one to announce from heavens that he is IN LOVE. Or to be overly affectionate, like SonSally portrays him AS.

He is most likely subtle, or doesn't care of romance at all. He has shown hesitation before when approaching Amy. In fact, sometimes, he hesitates saying soft and gentle things to her.

I am not saying he does like her or not. He never HAS given a direct ANSWER.

5: Plus, she. Would. Not. Sacrifice. Herself. To. Get. Roboticized. Like. Sally. Did.
That was a really big sacrifice Sally made, and most Sonamy fans are happy about that which makes me sick.

You clearly don't know Amy.

1: She said that she'd choose the world over Sonic, whilst Sally said she'd choose her kingdom.

2: Yes. Amy would have. She has sacrificed herself for sonic alot of times. She always comes head on when she finds out that Sonic is in trouble. Like in Sonic 06? She knew she could have gotten hurt, but yet she threw herself in front of him without hesitation. Shielding him from Silver's wrath.

3: What about her falling on her knees for Sonic when others tried to comfort her she refused when Sonic 'died' in Sonic '06. She let Elise kiss her love for his own good will.

We are happy that Sally has finally moved out of the way, so amy could at least get A ONE SHOT. I never say "she is a mary-sue whom should get robotized!" Do you not notice that Amy, no matter how much her arms are open, no matter how much she proves her loyalty, she sits as a rebound girl. She sits and watches her LOVE OF HER LIFE, off with another girl. Does she get 'jealous' as Sally did to Mina and Sonic? No. She acknowledges her boundaries and refrains herself from them. Other, FAN GIRLS wouldn't do that. They would whine and scream and call the woman off with their man, a whore, etc.

We are also glad Sally gotten robotized because...

- She was always the center of attention in alot of comics. We didn't like the fact it was always about her and SonAlly.

- It gave A PLOT.

Well, Sorry if that was wrong.

You said feel free to rant c:
SepperAlways7 Featured By Owner Jun 29, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Thanks for that really.

However, it doesn't really stop me from liking Sonally.

Besides, that comment I posted was quite old and I'm sure the stamp is too.

I honestly don't care about this whole Sally and Amy crap anymore. :/
I moved on from this and it surprised me that you would bring this back to my attention
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jun 30, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter
No problem!

I never wanted you to stop liking SonAlly ;)!

I like Sally AND Amy, both have potential.

Oops, sorry bout that!
SepperAlways7 Featured By Owner Jun 30, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
No worries!

I do like them both as well :D

I'll be honest, that whole rant was based on knowledge I've gathered.
I'm still new to the whole Sonic fandom and I used to hate Sonamy shippers, but I never posted hate comments.

You gave me a better perspective on Amy than what I thought she was.

Thank you for not hating on me!
I was quite afraid I was gonna get hate ^^"
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jul 1, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter

I hate my own fan's stupid attitude which are of my ship. They are fanbrats who can't handle opinions or diversity. They WORSHIP Amy, which is no need too, and bash Sally. Ugh, so annoying.

FUNNY thing, i grew up with Sally (hence SATAM was only on Netflix with Sonic UNDERGROUND), and SonAlly, but I didn't appeal in their relationship. I honestly was neutral and skimmed over it, (But I like it in SATAM rather in the comics. I would ship them there.). When I met Amy, and Sonic's foreplay, I just liked it.

Yes, don't buy into want the anti's say. They usually twist a great character and nitpick on HALF of the things Amy does, and twist her into an abuser.

I would never hate a fellow Sonic fan, hate isn't me. ;)!

I would just disrespectfully agree! And if you do get hate, you expect me to jump to your aid ya here? xD!
SepperAlways7 Featured By Owner Jul 4, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Ah thanks dude :)

I'm glad we compromised this
SonicBoom-zers Featured By Owner Jul 5, 2016  Hobbyist Artisan Crafter

Freak-Ops Featured By Owner Oct 17, 2015  Student Digital Artist
That's for you, for me... It's makes sense.
jjyojay Featured By Owner Oct 1, 2015
i hate sonally to sonamy is way better
jjyojay Featured By Owner Sep 27, 2015
good to know 
Toni-the-Mink Featured By Owner Apr 26, 2015  Hobbyist Writer
I have to fave just because your make the most valid of points
FireWoman21 Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2015
I agree. The reason I don't like this couple is because it confuses me. Because I've seen Sally treating Sonic like he's a dumbass and other times she's back to loving him and saying he's smart. Come on, Sally, make up your mind! Do you love the guy or not?
Add a Comment:

Featured in Collections

Stamps I love by RoyalBigBlue

Other stamps by 300Madness


Submitted on
January 17, 2012
Image Size
12.3 KB


6,429 (7 today)
218 (who?)